- Morning Scoop AI
- Posts
- đ€ Open vs. Closed AI: The DeepSeek Dilemma
đ€ Open vs. Closed AI: The DeepSeek Dilemma
đ We made itâ50 editions of Morning Scoop AI
Huge thanks for being part of the journey so far. We're just getting started, and the next 50 are going to be even bigger. Letâs dive in! đ
In todayâs scoop đš
đ€ Open vs. Closed AI: The DeepSeek Dilemma
đ©ș NHS Rolls Out AI for Breast Cancer Screening
đ¶ The Beatles Just Won a Grammy... With a Little Help From AI
đ§ 3 Trending AI Tools
đ€ Open vs. Closed AI: The DeepSeek Dilemma

AI's version of the "sharing is caring" debate just hit DEFCON 1. China's DeepSeek AI has reignited a fiery discussion in the U.S.: should AI research be an open playground for all, or should Uncle Sam treat it like a state secret?
đ The Open-Source Dream
Meta, Mistral, and DeepSeek believe in the open-source model: sharing AI breakthroughs so anyone can build on them. The argument? Collaboration fuels progress:
đ Faster innovation â Engineers worldwide can refine and improve models.
đ Cheaper AI development â Open models lower the cost for startups and researchers.
đȘ More competition, less monopoly â No single company hoards AI power.
Tim Dettmers, a researcher whose work was cited by DeepSeek, never directly worked with the company but saw his research contribute to their breakthrough. While he acknowledges the impact of knowledge-sharing, he emphasizes that the open-source model has kept the U.S. at the forefront of AI innovation.
đ The Closed-Source Counterpunch
On the flip side, some believe that making AI research openly accessible is like handing blueprints for a nuclear reactor to the entire internet. Investor Vinod Khosla likened it to sharing the Manhattan Project â the ultra-secretive WWII effort that built the atomic bomb. The concerns?
đš National security risks â What happens if adversaries weaponize AI?
đ° Profit protection â Companies like OpenAI argue that keeping models proprietary safeguards their billion-dollar investments.
đ© Preventing AI misuse â Open AI models could be repurposed for deepfakes, cyberattacks, and other shady business.
đĄ The DeepSeek Catalyst
DeepSeekâs latest AI models are open and powerful â and they might have learned a thing or two from OpenAI. Some suggest they "distilled" knowledge from OpenAI's models. This has Washington on high alert, prompting calls for tighter controls on advanced AI chips and research.
The Verdict? Even OpenAIâs CEO, Sam Altman, is having second thoughts about being a closed shop, admitting theyâve been "on the wrong side of history" regarding open-source AI. But he also knows spilling all their secrets isnât exactly the companyâs top priority.
So, should AI be a global group project or a classified operation? One thingâs clear: the genieâs out of the bottle, and itâs not going back in.
đ©ș NHS Rolls Out AI for Breast Cancer Screening

The NHS is making a bold move in the fight against breast cancer by launching the world's largest AI-powered screening trial. If this goes well, it could mean faster diagnoses, lighter workloads for radiologists, and a significant shake-up in cancer care.
đź The Big Picture:
The NHS will test AI on 700,000 mammograms over the next few years.
AI will analyze two-thirds of the scans to see if it's as good as human radiologists.
The hope? AI can serve as a "second reader," allowing hospitals to cut radiologist workload in half and speed up test results.
The study is backed by ÂŁ11 million in government funding and will take place across 30 NHS screening centers.
đĄ Why This Matters:
Every year, 55,000 people in the UK are diagnosed with breast cancer.
The current system requires two radiologists to review each mammogram for accuracy. AI could make it possible for just one radiologist to do the job, with AI acting as the second pair of eyes.
More than 2 million mammograms are performed annuallyâfreeing up even a fraction of radiologists' time would be a game-changer for NHS efficiency.
đ Whatâs Being Tested?
Five different AI systems will analyze 462,000 scans, while the remaining 238,000 will be reviewed the traditional way (by two radiologists). The goal is to compare results and ensure AI maintains accuracy without increasing false positives.
đ The Challenges:
AI has huge potential, but experts caution it needs to work equally well across different demographics to avoid bias.
The NHS is already short on radiologistsâexpected to be 40% understaffed by 2028âso AI could be a much-needed solution if it proves reliable.
Full results will take years, but early trials in Sweden suggest AI could cut radiologist workload by half without increasing errors.
đ Final Thought
If successful, this trial could redefine how breast cancer is detected, offering faster diagnoses and easing NHS backlogs. The UK government is also using this as a stepping stone for a dedicated National Cancer Plan aimed at making Britain a world leader in cancer survival.
The future of AI-powered healthcare is unfoldingâone scan at a time.
đ¶ The Beatles Just Won a Grammy... With a Little Help From AI
The Beatles just pulled off a musical resurrection worthy of a sci-fi blockbuster. Their latest track, Now and Then, won Best Rock Performance at the Grammysâ55 years after the band broke up. And the craziest part? AI played a crucial role in making it happen.
đ AI Didnât Write the SongâIt Cleaned It Up
No, weâre not living in a dystopian future where LennonGPT is cranking out Beatles hits. Instead, AI was used to restore a decades-old John Lennon demo, separating his vocals from a noisy piano recording. The technologyâsimilar to the noise reduction software in Zoom and FaceTimeâhelped make his voice crystal clear.
đ Why Not Release It Sooner?
The Beatles actually tried reviving Now and Then in the â90s, but audio tech back then just wasnât up to snuff. It wasnât until 2022âwhen Peter Jacksonâs team (yes, the Lord of the Rings guy) used AI to clean up old Beatles recordings for the Get Back documentaryâthat McCartney and Starr realized they could finally complete the song.
đ€ The Industryâs AI Dilemma
AI in music is a hot topic. Some artists worry about deepfake tracks and AI-generated vocals stealing their style. But in this case, AI wasnât used to fabricate anythingâit simply enhanced what was already there. Even the Grammys gave it the green light, stating that AI-assisted work is eligible as long as humans are the primary creators.
đ A Win for Musicâand for Tech
Sean Ono Lennon, Johnâs son, summed it up: âMy dad would have loved that. He was never shy to experiment with recording technology.â
So, while AI might be stirring up controversy in the music biz, it just helped The Beatles add another Grammy to their collection.
đ§3 Trending AI Tools
đ ChatGPT Deep Research - AI agent powered by OpenAI, designed for independent deep research, intelligently browsing text, images, and PDFs while leveraging web browsing and Python analysis.
đ© Teamsaver.ai - AI agent that gathers daily team updates via email and delivers smart summaries, helping you track productivity, celebrate top performers, and streamline team insights effortlessly.
đ Tana - AI-powered workspace that transforms your notes into actionable insights, helping tech-savvy professionals stay organized and focused without the busywork.
đ 50 editions of Morning Scoop AIâthanks to you!
Today marks our 50th newsletter, and we couldnât have done it without you! Whether youâve been here from the start or just joined the ride, we truly appreciate your support. đ
But weâre just getting started. The next 50? Bigger, better, and packed with even more AI goodness. And we want to grow this communityâso if you enjoy these scoops, share it with a friend whoâd love to stay ahead of the AI curve.
Hereâs to the next 50! Until tomorrowâstay curious! đ